Amendment 3 passed Nov. 3, and Winter Garden projects it will cut city property tax revenue by about $5.2 million in 2027. The loss grows to $8.5 million in 2028.
Updated Nov. 4: Florida voters approved Amendment 3 on Nov. 3 with about 62% of the vote statewide, in the Division of Elections’ unofficial results. It won 50.9% in Orange County. The city had posted no statement on the result by Wednesday afternoon. See our results story.
Winter Garden expects to lose about $5.2 million in property tax revenue in 2027 now that voters have approved Amendment 3. The city puts the loss at about $8.5 million in 2028, once the amendment is fully phased in.
The figures are on the city’s Amendment 3 ballot information page. It is part of a budget and finance portal the city launched in August and updated Oct. 1.
The city says it “does not advocate for or against any ballot measure.” State law bars local governments from spending public money to campaign on one, the page says.
What Amendment 3 changes
The city’s page summarizes the amendment this way:
- The homestead exemption, typically $50,000 now, rises to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028. It applies to every tax except school district taxes.
- The yearly cap on assessment increases for non-homestead property, such as second homes and commercial buildings, falls from 10% to 5%.
- New residents need five years of Florida residency to qualify for the larger exemption.
- Both exemptions then rise with inflation.
- Tax rates above the rollback rate need a two-thirds vote of the governing body. Rates more than 10% above it need a unanimous vote.
- The Legislature sets a schedule for phasing out non-school property taxes on homesteads.
Constitutional amendments in Florida need at least 60% of the vote to pass. Amendment 3 cleared that with about 62% statewide.
The city’s numbers
Winter Garden collected $30.3 million in property taxes in its 2026 budget year, the city says. Its projections:
| Projected loss | Share of property tax revenue | Share of general fund | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2027 ($150,000 exemption) | about $5.2 million | 17% | about 8% |
| 2028 ($250,000 exemption) | about $8.5 million | 28% | about 13% |
The projections assume a city tax rate of 4.8565 mills. They also assume 15,226 residential properties, of which 10,526, or about 70%, are homesteaded. The city says the numbers depend on the final legislation, data from the Orange County Property Appraiser and the vote itself.
What property tax pays for
Property tax covers about 48% of the city’s general fund spending, according to the page. The general fund is the $63.8 million budget for day-to-day services.
Public safety is the largest piece, at $38.4 million. The city notes that this alone is $8.1 million more than all the property tax it collects.
The rest of the adopted general fund, according to the city’s table:
- general government: $9.6 million
- culture and recreation: $6.1 million
- physical environment: $4.5 million
- transportation: $3.2 million
- economic environment: $1.4 million
- public assistance and debt service: $0.6 million
The same page also gives public safety as $36.7 million, or 58.6% of the general fund, in its questions and answers. It does not explain the difference from the $38.4 million in its table.
Try the budget yourself
The portal has three parts:
- a budget prioritization tool that lets you raise or cut each department’s budget to cover the lost revenue, with a 10-question survey on fees, assessments and service cuts
- the Amendment 3 page with the figures above
- a budget transparency report with trends in revenue, spending, staffing and tax rates
What it means for you
- If you own and live in your Winter Garden home, the larger exemption lowers the city and county parts of your tax bill. School taxes do not change.
- The city says a smaller budget could mean less money for public safety, infrastructure and other services. It has not said which services it would cut.
- You can tell the city your priorities through the survey in the budget tool.
- Amendment 3 passed on Nov. 3. The Orange County and statewide results are in our election results story.
- How your bill is worked out now is on our property taxes page.
Questions about the city’s figures go to City Hall at 407-656-4111.
Have your say