The typical Winter Garden home was worth $568,910 in September 2026, Zillow says: up $537 on the month, down 0.5% on the year and 5% below the May 2024 peak.

Last checked Oct. 20, 2026. Figures come from Zillow Research (the Zillow Home Value Index for September 2026, the latest month published), the Federal Housing Finance Agency house price index and the U.S. Census Bureau. This page is refreshed monthly.

Winter Garden home values have eased slightly after the run-up of 2021 and 2022. The typical home in the city was worth $568,910 in September 2026, according to the Zillow Home Value Index, down 0.5% from $571,994 a year earlier and about 5% below the city’s peak of $600,238 in May 2024. September’s $537 gain was the first monthly rise since February (our September story).

Updated Oct. 20: figures moved to September 2026. Zillow revised its earlier months with this release, so August 2026 now reads $568,373 (first published as $566,535) and the May 2024 peak $600,238 (was $598,298). For property records and assessed values, call the Orange County Property Appraiser at 407-836-5044.

What this means for you

The numbers

Area Typical value, September 2026 September 2025 One-year change
Winter Garden $568,910 $571,994 -0.5%
Windermere $709,948 $704,406 0.8%
Clermont $427,392 $434,521 -1.6%
Ocoee $414,035 $417,775 -0.9%
Orange County $400,964 $404,252 -0.8%
Orlando $372,775 $376,771 -1.1%

Zillow’s index tracks the typical value of all homes, single-family and condo, in the middle third of the market, smoothed and seasonally adjusted. It is an estimate of value, not a median sale price. Winter Garden’s typical value runs about $168,000 above the Orange County figure and about $155,000 above neighboring Ocoee.

Ten years of values

Line chart of Zillow's typical Winter Garden home value each September: $305,408 in 2016, $383,384 in 2020, $580,369 in 2022, $597,858 in 2024 and $568,910 in 2026

The typical value nearly doubled in a decade, from $305,408 in September 2016 to $568,910 in September 2026. Most of the rise came in two years: from $383,384 in September 2020 to $580,369 in September 2022, a 51% jump. Values then flattened, peaked in May 2024 and drifted down by small amounts most months after that. Over the 12 months to September 2026 the index moved within about $3,600.

The wider Orlando market

The Federal Housing Finance Agency’s all-transactions index for the Orlando-Kissimmee-Sanford metro area stood at 457.07 in the second quarter of 2026, up 0.8% from 453.33 a year earlier. That index follows repeat sales and refinance appraisals of the same homes, so it measures price change, not price level. It suggests the metro area as a whole has held roughly steady while Winter Garden’s index edged down.

What the Census says

The Census Bureau’s 2023 American Community Survey five-year estimates put the median value of owner-occupied homes in Winter Garden at $428,200. That figure is what owners said their homes were worth, pooled across 2019 to 2023, so it runs well below the 2026 Zillow estimate. See our Winter Garden population guide for more Census figures.

Before you buy

  • Confirm the address is inside the city limits. Many Winter Garden mailing addresses are in unincorporated Orange County, which changes who collects your trash, who sets part of your tax rate and who answers a 911 call.
  • If the home is in a community development district, its assessment is added to the property tax bill. Ask for the amount before you make an offer, and read our property tax guide.
  • File for the homestead exemption by March 1 after you move in.
  • Check school zones in our schools guide, and see our moving to Winter Garden guide for utilities and services.
  • Compare the city’s areas, from Historic Downtown to Johns Lake, in our Winter Garden neighborhoods guide.

Frequently asked questions

What is the average home price in Winter Garden?

Zillow’s typical home value for the city of Winter Garden was $568,910 in September 2026. That is an estimate of value for homes in the middle of the market, not a sale price.

Are Winter Garden home prices going down?

Slightly. Zillow’s typical value fell 0.5% from September 2025 to September 2026 and sits about 5% below its May 2024 peak of $600,238. September was the first monthly rise since February.

How much have Winter Garden home prices risen since 2020?

The typical value rose from $383,384 in September 2020 to $568,910 in September 2026, about 48%, Zillow’s index shows.

Is Winter Garden more expensive than Orange County?

Yes. Winter Garden’s typical value of $568,910 in September 2026 compared with $400,964 for Orange County as a whole, Zillow says.