Winter Garden's typical home value rose $537 in September to $568,910, Zillow says, its first monthly gain since February. It is still down 0.5% on the year.

The typical Winter Garden home gained value in September for the first time since February. It rose $537 to $568,910, according to the Zillow Home Value Index published this month.

That ends six straight monthly dips. It is a small move, about 0.1%, and the year still shows a loss. The typical value is down $3,084, or 0.5%, from $571,994 in September 2025.

Where the number stands

  • September 2026: $568,910
  • August 2026: $568,373, revised up from the $566,535 Zillow first published
  • September 2025: $571,994
  • Peak: $600,238 in May 2024. September’s figure is $31,328, or 5.2%, below it.
  • September 2020: $383,384. Values are still about 48% higher than six years ago.
Line chart of Zillow's typical Winter Garden home value each month from September 2025 to September 2026. It starts at $571,994, drifts down to $568,373 in August 2026 and rises to $568,910 in September 2026.
The typical value has moved within about $3,600 for a year. Chart by Winter Garden Journal
Share this chartFacebookWhatsAppX

Zillow’s index is an estimate of value for homes in the middle third of the market, single-family and condo, smoothed and seasonally adjusted. It is not a median sale price, and Zillow revises earlier months as new sales come in. That is why August’s figure changed.

How the neighbors compare

Most of west Orange County and nearby Lake County was still down on the year in September. Oakland, Windermere, Gotha and Doctor Phillips were the exceptions, with small gains.

Place Typical value, September 2026 Change from September 2025
Windermere, about six miles southeast $709,948 +0.8%
Montverde, about seven miles northwest $687,141 -0.1%
Oakland, about three miles west $570,276 +2.2%
Winter Garden $568,910 -0.5%
Doctor Phillips, about nine miles southeast $535,356 +0.3%
Gotha, about five miles east $502,043 +0.5%
Clermont, about eight miles west $427,392 -1.6%
Ocoee, about four miles northeast $414,035 -0.9%
Orange County $400,964 -0.8%
Apopka, about 12 miles northeast $394,805 -0.3%
Orlando, about 17 miles east $372,775 -1.1%
Groveland, about 14 miles west $367,343 -3.0%

Source: Zillow Home Value Index, September 2026. Distances are from the center of Winter Garden to the center of each place, measured on Census Bureau coordinates.

Oakland, the small town on Winter Garden’s western edge, had the biggest gain on the list. Its typical value is now $1,366 above Winter Garden’s. Groveland had the biggest fall.

Winter Garden’s typical home is worth about $168,000 more than the Orange County figure and about $155,000 more than one in Ocoee.

Horizontal bar chart of Zillow's typical home value in September 2026: Windermere $709,948, Montverde $687,141, Oakland $570,276, Winter Garden $568,910, Doctor Phillips $535,356, Gotha $502,043, Clermont $427,392, Ocoee $414,035, Orange County $400,964, Apopka $394,805, Orlando $372,775, Groveland $367,343.
Winter Garden sits in the middle of the west Orange County range. Chart by Winter Garden Journal
Share this chartFacebookWhatsAppX

Rents slipped

Asking rents went the other way. Zillow’s Observed Rent Index put the typical Winter Garden asking rent at $2,352 in September. That is down from $2,362 in August, about 0.4%, and down 0.5% from $2,365 a year earlier.

What it means for you

  • For owners, little has changed. The typical home is worth about what it was a year ago, and about 5% less than at the 2024 peak.
  • For buyers, September does not mark a turn. One monthly rise of $537 follows six small declines, and Zillow may revise it.
  • Your tax bill does not come from Zillow. Assessed values come from the Orange County Property Appraiser, 407-836-5044. Our property tax guide explains how the bill is worked out, and our Amendment 3 explainer covers the Nov. 3 ballot question.
  • For recorded sale prices, see our weekly real estate transfers page. The full picture, with 10 years of values, is on our Winter Garden home prices page.